Broken Toilet? Common Toilet Problems And How To Fix Them

broken toilet

Do you have a broken toilet? Dealing with common toilet issues like slow-filling, running, leaking, noisy, or clogged toilets doesn’t always necessitate calling a plumber. Many of these problems can be addressed with basic do-it-yourself (DIY) fixes. By understanding the mechanics of a toilet and its various components, you gain the knowledge needed to troubleshoot and resolve issues effectively.

From diagnosing a toilet base leak to tackling a toilet that won’t flush, learning the fundamentals empowers you to handle minor repairs confidently and efficiently. With the right tools and some know-how, you can save time and money by fixing your broken toilet on your own, ensuring your bathroom functions smoothly and hassle-free.

How Does A Toilet Work?

How does a toilet work? A toilet operates on a simple yet efficient mechanism designed to facilitate waste removal and maintain sanitation in households. When you press the toilet handle, it lifts the flush valve, allowing water stored in the tank to rush into the bowl.

This sudden influx of water creates a siphon effect, pulling waste and water down the drain pipe and into the sewer system. As the tank empties, a fill valve opens to refill the tank with clean water from the supply line. This process restores the toilet to its ready state for the next use. Critical components of a toilet include:

broken toilet

Flush valve: Releases water from the tank into the bowl to initiate the flushing process.

Fill valve: Regulates the water level in the tank by allowing clean water to enter.

Flapper: Seals the flush valve to prevent water from leaking into the bowl when the tank is full.

Handle: Activates the flushing mechanism by lifting the flush valve when pressed.

Trapway: The curved channel beneath the bowl carries waste and water away from the toilet and into the drain pipe.

Understanding these components and how they function together is essential for diagnosing and resolving common toilet problems.

broken toilet

Toilet Repair Considerations

When tackling toilet repairs by yourself, it’s essential to proceed with caution and keep several tips in mind to ensure the process goes smoothly:

  • Adhere to all local codes relevant to your plumbing repairs.
  • If the pointers provided below don’t resolve your toilet issues, or if you’re unsure or have concerns about the repair work, it’s wise to seek the expertise of a certified plumber.
  • Handle connectors and fasteners gently to prevent damage. Wrapping pliers or wrench jaws with tape can shield metal fastener finishes from scratches. Be mindful not to over-tighten nuts, bolts, or connectors, as excessive force can lead to cracks in the toilet or damage to plastic components.
  • When lifting the tank lid, do so carefully and store it in a secure location to prevent any breakage.
  • Verify that the replacement parts you buy are compatible with your toilet model. Taking the part you intend to replace in the store could assist in finding an accurate match.

Remember, meticulous attention and the right tools are the keys to a successful DIY plumbing job without unexpected complications.


Loose Toilet Handle

Fixing a loose toilet handle is a relatively simple task. Here’s how you can do it:

Identify the Problem: Determine whether the handle is loose because the mounting nut holding it in place has become loose or if the handle itself is damaged.

Turn Off the Water: Locate the shut-off valve behind the toilet and turn it clockwise to shut off the water supply to the toilet.

Remove the Tank Lid: Lift off the tank lid and set it aside in a safe place.


broken toilet loose handle

Tighten the Mounting Nut: Inside the tank, locate the mounting nut securing the toilet handle to the tank. Use an adjustable wrench or pliers to tighten the mounting nut by turning it clockwise. Be careful not to overtighten, as this could damage the nut or the handle.

Check for Damage: If the handle itself is damaged or cracked, you may need to replace it. Remove the handle by unscrewing the mounting nut inside the tank and pulling the handle out.

Replace the Handle (if necessary): Purchase a new toilet handle assembly from a hardware store or home improvement center. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions to install the new handle, including attaching the lever arm to the flush valve and securing the mounting nut inside the tank.

Test the Handle: Turn the water supply back on by turning the shut-off valve counterclockwise. Flush the toilet to test the handle and ensure that it operates smoothly without any looseness or wobbling.

Adjust if Necessary: If the handle is still loose after tightening the mounting nut or replacing the handle, you may need to adjust the length of the chain or rod connecting the handle to the flush valve inside the tank. Ensure that there is enough slack in the chain or rod to allow for proper flushing without causing tension on the handle.

By following these steps, you can fix a loose toilet handle and restore proper functionality to your toilet.

Toilet Won’t Flush

If your toilet won’t flush, it’s usually due to one of the following reasons, along with their respective solutions:

Check the Water Supply: Ensure that the water supply valve, usually located behind the toilet near the floor, is fully open. If it’s closed or partially closed, turn it counterclockwise to open it completely.

Inspect the Flush Handle: Sometimes, the problem lies with the flush handle or the mechanism inside the tank. Open the tank and check if the chain or lift arm is properly connected to the flush lever. Adjust or reconnect them if necessary.

Check the Flapper Valve: Lift the flapper valve (the rubber piece at the bottom of the tank) and see if the toilet flushes properly. If it does, the flapper valve may not seal properly, causing water to leak from the tank into the bowl continuously. Clean the flapper or replace it if it’s damaged or worn out.

Inspect the Fill Valve: The fill valve, also known as the ballcock, regulates the water level in the tank. If it’s malfunctioning or stuck, it may prevent the tank from filling properly after flushing. Adjust or replace the fill valve if necessary.

Check for Clogs: A clog in the toilet bowl or the drainpipe can also prevent the toilet from flushing properly. Use a plunger to try and dislodge the clog. If the plunger doesn’t work, you may need to use a toilet auger to remove the obstruction from the drainpipe.

Inspect the Water Level: If the water level in the tank is too low, the toilet may not flush properly. Adjust the float arm or the fill valve to raise the water level to the recommended mark inside the tank.

Clean the Rim Feed Holes: Sometimes, mineral deposits or debris can clog the rim feed holes under the rim of the toilet bowl, affecting the flushing performance. Use a wire hanger or a small brush to clean these holes and restore proper flushing.

You can often fix a toilet that won’t flush and restore proper functionality to your bathroom plumbing by troubleshooting these common issues. If the problem persists or you’re unsure about performing the repairs, consider contacting a professional plumber for assistance.

Toilet Leaks

Fixing a leaking toilet involves identifying the source of the leak and addressing it accordingly. Here are some steps to fix a broken toilet that leaks water:

Check the Wax Ring: The wax ring seals the connection between the toilet base and the drainpipe. If it’s damaged or worn out, water can leak from the base of the toilet. To replace the wax ring, you’ll need to turn off the water supply, remove the toilet, scrape off the old wax ring, and install a new one.

Inspect the Tank Components: Leaks from the tank can occur due to several reasons. Check the tank components, including the fill valve, flush valve, bolts, and gaskets, for any signs of damage or deterioration. Tighten loose bolts and replace damaged parts as needed.

Check the Water Supply Line: Inspect the water supply line that connects the toilet tank to the water supply valve on the wall. Look for any cracks, corrosion, or loose connections. Tighten loose fittings or replace the supply line if it’s damaged.

Inspect the Flush Valve and Flapper: The flush valve and flapper control the flow of water from the tank to the bowl during flushing. If the flapper is worn out or doesn’t seal properly, water can leak into the bowl continuously. Replace the flapper if it’s damaged or worn out.

Check the Overflow Tube: The overflow tube prevents the tank from overfilling by diverting excess water into the bowl. If the water level in the tank is too high, it can overflow through the overflow tube and leak onto the floor. Adjust the water level in the tank to the recommended mark to prevent overflow.

Inspect the Tank and Bowl Seals: Leaks can also occur where the tank meets the bowl. Inspect the seals between the tank and bowl for any signs of damage or deterioration. Replace the seals if necessary to prevent leaks.

Check for Cracks or Damage: Finally, inspect the toilet tank and bowl for any cracks or damage that could cause leaks. If you find any cracks, you may need to replace the entire toilet to prevent further leaks.

By identifying and addressing the source of the leak, you can effectively fix a toilet that leaks water and prevent water damage to your bathroom floor and surrounding areas. If you’re unsure about performing the repairs, consider hiring a professional plumber.

running toilet

Toilet Won’t Stop Running

If your toilet won’t stop running, it’s likely due to a flush or fill valve problem. Here’s how you can fix a broken toilet that won’t stop running:

Check the Flush Valve and Flapper: Lift the lid off the toilet tank and inspect the flush valve and flapper. The flapper is the rubber piece that seals the flush valve. Sometimes, the flapper can become warped, worn, or misaligned, preventing it from sealing properly. Adjust or replace the flapper if necessary.

Adjust the Flapper Chain: If the flapper chain is too loose or too tight, it can prevent the flapper from sealing properly. Adjust the chain length so there’s some slack, allowing the flapper to close completely after flushing.

Inspect the Fill Valve: The fill valve refills the toilet tank after flushing. If the fill valve is faulty or worn out, it can cause the toilet to run continuously. Check the fill valve for any signs of damage, such as leaks or corrosion. If the fill valve is malfunctioning, consider replacing it with a new one.

Check the Water Level: The water level in the tank should be set to the recommended mark, usually indicated on the overflow tube. If the water level is too high, it can cause the toilet to run continuously. Adjust the float arm or float cup on the fill valve to lower the water level in the tank.

Inspect the Float: The float is attached to the fill valve and controls the water level in the tank. If the float is damaged or improperly adjusted, it can cause the toilet to run continuously. Make sure the float moves freely and isn’t obstructed by the tank walls or other components.

Clean or Replace the Fill Valve: A fill valve clogged with debris may not function properly. Remove the fill valve and clean it thoroughly with vinegar or a descaling solution to remove any buildup. If cleaning doesn’t resolve the issue, consider replacing the fill valve with a new one.

Check for Other Leaks: In some cases, a toilet that won’t stop running may be due to a hidden leak in the toilet tank or bowl. Add a few drops of food coloring to the tank and wait a few minutes. If the water in the bowl changes color, it indicates a leak between the tank and bowl, which will need to be repaired.

By following these steps, you can diagnose and fix a toilet that won’t stop running, restore it to proper functioning, and prevent water waste. If you’re unsure about performing the repairs yourself, consider contacting a professional plumber for assistance.

Common Toilet Problems FAQs

Strange noises coming from the toilet can indicate various issues, including a running toilet, a malfunctioning fill valve, a loose washer or nut, or a clogged drain pipe. If you hear gurgling, hissing, or whistling sounds, it’s essential to identify and address the underlying cause to prevent further damage and water waste.

A gurgling noise in the toilet bowl often indicates a clog or obstruction in the drain pipe or vent stack. This obstruction can prevent air from flowing freely through the plumbing system, causing the water to gurgle as it drains. To resolve the issue, try using a plunger to clear the clog or contact a plumber for professional assistance.

Toilet sweating occurs when warm, humid air in the bathroom comes into contact with the cold surface of the toilet tank, causing condensation to form. To prevent toilet sweating, consider installing a toilet tank liner or insulation kit to help regulate the temperature of the tank. You can also reduce humidity levels in the bathroom by using a ventilation fan or opening a window during showers.

Loud noises during flushing can indicate several potential problems, such as a worn flapper, a malfunctioning fill valve, or high water pressure. Inspecting and replacing worn or damaged components, adjusting the water pressure, or installing a quiet fill valve can help reduce noise levels.

These are just a few common questions and answers related to broken toilet problems. If you encounter a more complex issue or are unsure how to proceed, it’s always best to consult a professional plumber for assistance.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Plumbing Experts

Trusted Plumbers For Over A Decade

Don’t Wait, Schedule An Appointment Today!

Recent Posts

Other Popular Blog Tags

Social Media

Related Posts

licensed plumber

How To Unclog A Garbage Disposal

Jessica had just finished preparing dinner when she noticed her kitchen sink draining slowly. Curious, she turned on the garbage disposal, hoping it would clear

Find A Plumber Near Me

How To Find A Local Plumber

Finding a reliable plumber can be a daunting task, especially when you’re faced with an urgent issue. Whether it’s a burst pipe, a clogged drain,

garbage disposal humming

Why Is My Garbage Disposal Humming?

Toilet issues are a common concern for homeowners, but those in Northern Virginia who prioritize maintenance experience fewer problems than those who neglect it. By